It seems the keeper of the world’s third largest advertising budget is a bit of a tease. Only the other day Joel Ewanick, General Motors global chief marketing officer, was telling us that, six months into the review, he simply couldn’t make up his mind about where to place GM’s $4.26bn advertising budget. Agencies on tenterhooks. Could there be a last minute reprieve for them?
No there could not. Actually, Ewanick had long since decided to give the largest chunk under review – the $3bn global media planning and buying business (bar India and China) – to Aegis-owned Carat. You read it here first, as long ago as early December.
If there was last-minute anguish over the decision, it more likely related to brinksmanship over Carat’s fee and the administrative nightmare of reducing a media roster of 40 down to a single agency.
That said, another part of the review may prove more of a poser for him. Ewanick has yet to pronounce on who will win creative duties for the mega-billion dollar Chevrolet account (it’s GM’s biggest brand, accounting for over half of vehicle sales). Omnicom-owned Goodby Silverstein & Partners looked safe with the bulk of the account since it was hired on Ewanick’s personal say-so soon after his arrival at GM. But there is talk that IPG agency McCann-Erickson – which already handles Chevy in India, China and Latin America – is destined to become the first Chevrolet global agency of record (ie, the senior partner).
We can only hope that, for the sake of embattled McCann Worldgroup chief Nick Brien, this rumour turns out to be true.
Because there is little solace to be found elsewhere. Universal McCann’s Latin American media business – sizeable and, more importantly, booming – will now be moving to Carat.
It could be worse though, Nick. Biggest casualty by far of the media consolidation (and indeed of the general review) is Publicis Groupe. PG’s media unit Starcom MediaVest has held the dominant US slice of the business since spring 2005 (back then, way before Lehman Bros and Chapter 11, it was worth $3.5bn a year).
Until now, PG has had a very strong year, mostly at WPP’s expense. Starcom managed to wrest the $600m Novartis account from MEC and its Digitas unit recently won the $1bn Sprint telecoms business. But the crushing GM media loss comes on top of other, collateral, damage. Big Fuel, the social media agency which Publicis seems to have acquired partly at Ewanick’s behest (it certainly came highly recommended) has overnight been reduced to a shell of its former self. By the self-same Ewanick’s unhelpful decision to move the GM account – about three-quarters of its income – elsewhere. Gives a new meaning to “Le Défi Americain”, doesn’t it?